K. Hyrkas et M. Paunonen-ilmonen, The effects of clinical supervision on the quality of care: examining the results of team supervision, J ADV NURS, 33(4), 2001, pp. 492-502
Aim(s) of the study. This study is part of a larger research project (1995-
1998) aiming at quality improvement by means of clinical supervision (CS).
The purpose of the study is to ascertain the conceptions of five ward teams
having CS of its effects on the quality of care.
Background. The quality of nursing care has been debated since at least the
1980s. An extensive literature and research reports describe a variety of
interventions and methods to improve the quality of care. One of the interv
entions is CS. However, the amount of empirical research exploring the effe
cts of CS especially on the quality of care is limited.
Method. Data were collected using group interviews and analysed using the m
ethod of phenomenography.
Findings. The following categories describing the conceptions related to CS
and to the quality of care emerged: knowledge, change and 'I and we as pro
viders of quality'. Conceptions of the effects varied between and within th
e teams and sometimes contradicted each other. The importance of knowledge
was underlined on three of the five wards. The patient's point of view emer
ged only on one ward.
Conclusions. It can be concluded that CS has effects on the quality of care
and it can be considered a quality improving intervention in nursing pract
ice. However, the knowledge of the different conceptions produced in this s
tudy also gives proof that team supervision is a challenge for supervisors.