M. Leuzinger-bohleber et al., Long-term effects of psychoanalysis and psychotherapy: A representative multiperspective follow-up study., PSYCHE-Z, 55(3), 2001, pp. 193-276
Citations number
102
Categorie Soggetti
Psycology
Journal title
PSYCHE-ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PSYCHOANALYSE UND IHRE ANWENDUNGEN
With competition getting fiercer on the psychotherapeutic market and public
funding cutbacks the order of the day, increasing pressure is being brough
t to bear on psychoanalysis to provide concrete medical evidence to substan
tiate its success claims. In this follow-up study based on a representative
sample of all clients completing courses of treatment with German Psychoan
alytic Association (DPV) analysts between 1990 and 1993, the authors square
up to the challenge of providing empirical evidence of the long-term effec
t of psychoanalyses and psychoanalytic therapies. In so doing they by no me
ans neglect the fundamental objections that can be leveled at such success-
measurement studies: Can psychotherapy success be empirically verified at a
ll! Who judges the results of psychotherapy! Are randomized, controlled out
come studies ethical! The result is a study which takes a critical look at
questions of method and combines qualitative psychoanalytic observations fr
om the follow-up interviews with quantitative approaches, delineating its p
osition on statistical design and representativeness, study design and meth
odological matters, and the conduct and multi-perspective evaluation of the
follow-up interviews. Selected findings on changes effected by treatment,
symptom stress, therapy satisfaction and treatment costs impressively demon
strate the significance of the study.