In vivo morphometry and functional analysis of human articular cartilage with quantitative magnetic resonance imaging - from image to data, from datato theory
F. Eckstein et al., In vivo morphometry and functional analysis of human articular cartilage with quantitative magnetic resonance imaging - from image to data, from datato theory, ANAT EMBRYO, 203(3), 2001, pp. 147-173
Analyses of form-function relationships and disease processes in human arti
cular cartilage necessitate in vivo assessment of cartilage morphology and
deformational behavior. MR imaging and advanced digital post-processing tec
hniques have opened novel possibilities for quantitative analysis of cartil
age morphology, structure, and function in health and disease. This article
reviews work on three-dimensional post-processing of MR image data of arti
cular cartilage, summarizing studies on the accuracy and precision of quant
itative analyses in human joints. It presents normative values on cartilage
volume, thickness, and joint surface areas in the human knee, and describe
s the correlation between different joints and joint surfaces as well as th
eir association with gender, body dimensions, and age. The article summariz
es ongoing work on functional adaptation of articular cartilage to mechanic
al loading, analyses of in situ cartilage deformation in intact joints in v
ivo and in vitro, and the quantitative evaluation of cartilage tissue loss
in osteoarthritis. We describe evolving techniques for assessment of the st
ructural/biochemical composition of articular cartilage, and discuss future
perspectives of quantitative cartilage imaging in the context of joint mec
hanics, mechano-adaptation, epidemiology, and osteoarthritis research. Spec
ifically, we show that fat-suppressed gradient echo sequences permit valid
analysis of cartilage morphology, both in healthy and severely osteoarthrit
ic joints, as well as highly reproducible measurements (CV%=1 to 3% in the
knee, and 2 to 10% in the ankle). Relatively small differences in cartilage
morphology exist between both limbs of the same person (similar to5%), but
large differences between individuals (CV% similar to 20%). Men display on
ly slightly thicker cartilage then women (similar to 10%), but significantl
y larger joint surface areas (similar to 25%), even when accounting for dif
ferences in body weight and height. Weight and height represent relatively
poor predictors of cartilage thickness (r(2) <15%), but muscle cross sectio
n areas display more promising correlations (r(2) >40%). The level of physi
cal exercise (sportive activity) does not account for interindividual diffe
rences in cartilage thickness. The thickness appears to decrease slightly i
n the elderly - in particular in women, even in the absence of osteoarthrit
ic cartilage lesions. Strenuous physical exercises (e.g., knee bends) cause
a 6% patellar cartilage deformation in young individuals, but significantl
y less deformation in elderly men and women (<3%). The time required for fu
ll recovery after exercise (fluid flow back into the matrix) is relatively
long (<similar to>90 min). Static in situ compression of femoropatellar car
tilage with 150% body weight produces large deformations after 4 h (similar
to 30% volume change), but only very little deformation during the first m
inutes of loading. Quantitative analyses of magnetization transfer and prot
on density hold promise for biochemical evaluation of articular cartilage,
and are shown to be related to the deformational behavior of the cartilage.
Application of these techniques to larger cohorts of patients in epidemiol
ogical and clinical studies will establish the role of quantitative cartila
ge imaging not only in basic research on form-function relationships of art
icular cartilage, but also in clinical research and management of osteoarth
ritis.