BACKGROUND. Because breast-conserving surgery (BCS), mastectomy alone, and
mastectomy with reconstruction are equally effective for the treatment of e
arly stage breast carcinoma, women's choice among them often focuses on qua
lity-of-life (QOL) issues. Information regarding QOL after these surgical t
reatments could help women with this decision.
METHODS. Participants in this prospective study were women, age 30-85 years
, with newly diagnosed breast carcinoma who underwent BCS (n = 103), mastec
tomy alone (n = 55), or mastectomy with reconstruction (n = 40). Quality of
life was assessed after diagnosis (baseline) and at 1, 3, 6, 12, 18, and 2
4 months after baseline by using the Mischel Uncertainty in Illness Scale,
Profile of Mood States, and Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy for Bre
ast Cancer.
RESULTS, In multivariate regression analyses controlling for the QOL score
obtained at baseline, age, and type of nonsurgical treatment, women who und
erwent mastectomy with reconstruction had greater mood disturbance (P = 0.0
02) and poorer well-being (P,= 0.002) after baseline than women who had mas
tectomy alone; these differences remained 18 months after surgery. Although
similar analyses also showed that women who underwent BCS had more mood di
sturbance than women who had mastectomy alone, this difference was signific
ant only at 12 months after baseline. The BCS and mastectomy-only group did
not differ significantly regarding well-being.
CONCLUSIONS. Aspects of QOL other than body image are not better in women w
ho undergo BCS or mastectomy with reconstruction than in women who have mas
tectomy alone. In fact, mastectomy with reconstruction is associated with g
reater mood disturbance and poorer well-being. (C) 2001 American Cancer Soc
iety.