This article provides a historical, philosophical, and theoretical ana
lysis of affirmative action in higher education. It begins with the hi
storical basis for affirmative action and the rationale for why it has
been needed. The author outlines the philosophy behind affirmative ac
tion and its legal ramifications. The article then evaluates the succe
ss of affirmative action, outlines the criticisms that have been made
of it, and considers alternatives. It is argued that affirmative actio
n goes to the heart of what we mean by public higher education and wha
t we mean by ''merit.'' Although the policy has not succeeded in creat
ing dramatic improvements, it has been consistent with basic assumptio
ns about the meaning of academic community.