Background Maternal nutritional factors have been implicated in the complex
aetiology of neural tube defects (NTD). We investigated whether the amount
of weight a woman gained during pregnancy was associated with her risk of
delivering an infant with an NTD.
Methods We conducted a population-based case-control study within the cohor
t of 708 129 live births and fetal deaths occurring in selected California
counties in 1989-1991. Face-to-face interviews were conducted with mothers
of 538 (88% of eligible) NTD cases (including those electively terminated,
stillborn, or liveborn) and with mothers of 539 (88%) non-malformed livebor
n controls within an average of 5 months from the term delivery date. Respo
ndent-reported weight gain during pregnancy (kg) was analysed. Risks of inf
ants having NTD were estimated among women who gained <10kg compared to tho
se who gained <greater than or equal to>10kg during greater than or equal t
o 38 week gestations.
Results Compared to women who gained greater than or equal to 10kg, an incr
eased risk for NTD offspring was observed among women who gained <10kg (odd
s ratio [OR] = 3.2, 95% CI: 2.3-4.6). The OR was 5.0 (95% CI: 2.6-9.7) amon
g those women who gained <5 kg during pregnancy. The increased risk was not
attributable to maternal non-use of a multivitamin containing folic acid,
diabetes, NTD-pregnancy history, age, race/ethnicity, education, gravidity,
alcohol use, cigarette use, prepregnant obesity, low socioeconomic status,
dieting, nausea, nor to lower dietary intakes of folate, zinc, energy, pro
tein, fat, carbohydrates, and methionine. An increased risk was observed ev
en after simultaneous adjustment for most of these factors (OR = 2.2, 95% C
I: 1.2-3.8). The risk associated with gaining <10kg was greater for anencep
haly, but still elevated for spina bifida.
Conclusions We did not have information on weight gain during early pregnan
cy. Because weight gain during the relevant embryological period for NTD (f
irst month postconception) is relatively small and often variable, it seems
less likely that elevated NTD risks indicate a causal association between
lowered weight gain throughout pregnancy and abnormal development of the ne
ural tube. It seems more likely that lowered weight gain is a consequence o
f carrying an NTD-affected fetus. However, what this consequence is and why
risk was substantially larger for anencephaly is unknown.