Using an arbitrary response, we evaluated fixed-time (FT) schedules that we
re either similar or dissimilar to a baseline (response-dependent) reinforc
ement schedule and extinction. Results suggested that both FT schedules and
extinction resulted in decreased responding. However, FT schedules were mo
re effective in reducing response rates if the FT reinforcer rate was dissi
milar to baseline reinforcer rates. Possible reasons for this difference we
re evaluated with data analysis methods designed to identify adventitious r
esponse-reinforcer relations.