In a series of four experiments, we investigated the conditions under which
target-absent responses are faster than target-present responses in visual
search. Previous experiments have shown that such an absent-advantage occu
rs mainly for homogeneous distracters arranged in a regular pattern. From t
hese results, it has been concluded that the absent-advantage is due to per
ceptual processes, such as grouping by similarity. Our data show that such
processes are not sufficient. Rather, the absent-advantage is the result of
interactions between perceptual and decisional processes. Certain perceptu
al conditions, such as randomizing stimulus patterns, lead to specific crit
eria settings that produce an absent-advantage. That such an account can ex
plain our main results is demonstrated by modeling our data with a modified
version of the Guided Search 2 model.