Over recent years, communication within the physician-patient relationship
has been profoundly changing. New modes of conveying diagnostic and therape
utic information influence the way in which decisions regarding treatment a
re made. We propose a critical review of the various theoretical models as
presented in the literature, from the paternalistic to the shared decision
model, in order to reveal conceptual ambiguities and their related methodol
ogical problems. This analysis leads to a project for clarifying these prob
lems through a research protocol based on shared decision-making. Copyright
(C) 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.