Concentration-effect relationship of intravenous alfentanil and ketamine on peripheral neurosensory thresholds, allodynia and hyperalgesia of neuropathic pain
A. Leung et al., Concentration-effect relationship of intravenous alfentanil and ketamine on peripheral neurosensory thresholds, allodynia and hyperalgesia of neuropathic pain, PAIN, 91(1-2), 2001, pp. 177-187
Both mu opioid agonists and N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist
s are implicated in the regulation of neuropathic pain in post-nerve injury
preclinical pain models. This study characterizes the effects of intraveno
usly infused alfentanil (a mu -receptor agonist) and ketamine (an NMDA-rece
ptor antagonist) on human neuropathic pain states, characterized by allodyn
ia and hyperalgesia. Using diphenhydramine as the placebo, alfentanil and k
etamine infusions were given in a randomized double-blind fashion 1 week ap
art via a computer-controlled infusion (CCI) pump that was programmed to ta
rget plasma levels of alfentanil at 25, 50 and 75 ng/ml and ketamine at 50,
100 and 150 ng/ml. At the beginning of each infusion and each targeted pla
sma level, baseline vital signs, neurosensory testing that included thermal
thresholds, thermal pain and von Frey filament thresholds, and spontaneous
and evoked pain scores were obtained. Moreover, the areas of allodynia or
hyperalgesia to stroking and a 5.18 von Frey filament were mapped at the be
ginning and the end of each infusion. A total of seven males and five femal
es with post-nerve injury allodynia and hyperalgesia were enrolled in the s
tudy. Elevations of cold, warm, hot pain and von Frey tactile thresholds we
re noted. Dose-dependent increases in cold and cold pain thresholds, and re
ductions in stroking pain scores were noted in both the alfentanil and the
ketamine infusions. In addition, alfentanil showed a statistically signific
ant dose-dependent reduction in both spontaneous and von Frey pain scores.
Both the alfentanil and ketamine infusions showed a reduction in the stroki
ng hyperalgesic area and ketamine showed a significant reduction in the von
Frey hyperalgesia area. No significant CNS side effects and changes in vit
al signs were noted. A partial deafferentation state was found in the post-
nerve injury patients who presented with allodynia and hyperalgesia. The ef
fects of alfentanil on cold and cold pain thresholds and spontaneous pain s
cores correlates with previous studies suggesting an opiate central analges
ic effect. In addition, the reduction of the hyperalgesic area and evoked p
ain scores with the alfentanil infusion suggests that opioids may have some
peripheral effects in the post-nerve injury patients. Therefore, clinical
utilization of opioids with careful titration may be beneficial in post-ner
ve injury patients with partial deafferentation. With the absence of signif
icant CNS side effects, the ketamine infusion not only demonstrated the wel
l-documented spinal cord mechanism of the NMDA receptor, but the result of
the current study also suggests that a peripheral mechanism of NMDA recepto
r may exist. The relationship between central sensitization and regulation
of peripheral NMDA-receptor expression requires further investigation. (C)
2001 International Association for the Study of Pain. published by Elsevier
Science B.V. All rights reserved.