We synthesized hexagonal YMnO3 doped with tetravalent Zr ions and studied t
he electronic and magnetic properties. Zr substitution creates a mixed Mn3-Mn2+ system, instead of the conventional Mn3+-Mn4+ of colossal magnetoresi
stance manganites. The YMnO3 system displays a pronounced asymmetry for ele
ctron and hole doping. Hole doping results in a conducting state, whereas e
lectron doping retains the insulating state. This asymmetry is a consequenc
e of the crystal field splitting of the Mn ions in trigonal bipyramidal coo
rdination.