Increases in soil bulk density beyond the optimum reduce land productivity
and, where soil is affected, may be difficult to remedy. Elucidating the me
chanisms causing compaction is a prerequisite to sustainable management of
fragile soils. We examined a dense grey soil in Western Australia in which
the dominant physical feature of the subsoil was coarse prismatic structure
. The prisms were approximately hexagonal in horizontal section with an ave
rage side length of 0.66 m. The top of the prisms reached to within approxi
mately 0.07 m of the soil surface, their sides becoming indistinguishable b
elow approximately 0.9 m. The vertical faces of the prisms were coated by m
aterial similar in composition to the topsoil and separated from it by a tr
ansition material of intermediate composition. Soil within the prisms had a
bulk density at maximum swelling which reached a maximum of 1.86 g cm(-3)
in the upper subsoil. We investigate the hypothesis that such a high bulk d
ensity could have developed as a result of a simple three-stage process: (i
) soil shrinkage as the profile dries over summer leading to widening of cr
acks between prismatic peds, (ii) infilling of cracks by detached topsoil w
hich adds to coating thickness, and (iii) swelling during the winter, now p
artially restricted by coating material, leading to compression of the pris
matic peds. We present a model which accounts quantitatively for this proce
ss and explain how soil physical characteristics might facilitate it. The d
ense upper subsoil (7-60 cm) limits root penetration and prolongs the perio
d of transient waterlogging of the topsoil during winter, adversely affecti
ng subsequent crop performance. Our work suggests that stabilizing surface
soil to minimize soil detachment could be a relevant management objective o
n these structurally unstable soils in order to prevent subsoil compaction.