The involvement of the H2OCl+ ion in the ClONO2 hydrolysis on an ice surfac
e is shown to be unlikely via quantum chemical calculations and comparative
analysis of infrared spectra of low temperature mixtures of H2O with HNO3,
N2O5 or ClONO2. For the ClONO2 hydrolysis on ice, the reaction path involv
ing H2OCl+ is estimated to be similar to 10- 14 kcal/mol higher in energy t
han the one involving H3O+ via proton transfer in the ice lattice. An analy
sis of literature infrared spectra, complemented by quantum chemical calcul
ations of the vibrational frequencies of the relevant species, indicates th
at the spectral feature previously assigned to H2OCl+ should instead be ass
igned to molecular HNO3.