We analyze a game theory model in which individuals foraging on a habitat c
ontinuum choose behaviors that are the "best responses" to the behaviors an
d densities of competitors. These behaviors determine community invasibilit
y and coexistence. By making fitness an explicit function of maintenance me
tabolic cost, we can show that changes in maintenance cost have an indirect
but important effect on the best response behaviors, and hence, on communi
ty dynamics. In particular, decreasing maintenance cost has the effect of d
ecreasing habitat resource levels by increasing the efficiency with which i
ndividuals convert resources into offspring. The resulting decrease in habi
tat resource levels increases each phenotype's relative foraging advantage
in whatever habitat(s) it holds an absolute advantage. As a result, more ph
enotypes can successfully invade the community. Indeed, low enough maintena
nce costs results in species inhabiting evolutionary minima in the adaptive
landscape, which promotes disruptive selection and provides the potential
for an evolutionary bifurcation.