Ms. Westerterp-plantenga, Analysis of energy density of food in relation to energy intake regulationin human subjects, BR J NUTR, 85(3), 2001, pp. 351-361
The relationship between energy density (ED) of food and drink consumption
ad libitum and energy intake (EI) was analysed. EI was taken as average dai
ly EI over the long term, and as EI during a single meal. Moreover, the dis
tribution of EI over three ED categories was analysed. Average daily EI was
related to ED of the food and drinks when ED was strongly influenced by sp
ecific macronutrients. When ED was strongly influenced by the weight of wat
er, it was not related to EI. During a meal subjects monitored mainly weigh
t, and to a lesser extent, the energy content of the food ingested. Therefo
re, covertly manipulated ED of a meal affected EI directly. The impact of E
D on EI was modulated by dietary behaviours such as restraint. Overt manipu
lation of ED for 6 months showed that EI was adjusted to a decreased but no
t to an increased ED in dietary-unrestrained subjects, and that EI was adju
sted to an increased but not to a decreased ED in dietary-restrained subjec
ts. Knowledge of ED was shown to lead to an inverse relationship between po
rtion sizes and ED during a meal. Average daily EI consisted of a distribut
ion of EI over the three different categories of ED, so that obese women at
e more of foods with a high ED and less of foods with a low ED compared wit
h normal weight women (and nutritional guidelines). In conclusion, ED affec
ted daily EI by means of macronutrient specific effects. EI from a meal wit
h an unknown ED can become inversely related to EI through learning or cond
itioning. Therefore, the effect of ED on EI during a single meal observatio
n cannot be extrapolated directly to the 24 h effect on El. With regard to
the treatment of obesity, a conscious decreased consumption of foods high i
n ED and an increase in consumption of low-ED food is necessary to decrease
and subsequently maintain body weight, particularly in subjects with a sed
entary lifestyle.