Classifications of tree species into regeneration guilds or functional grou
ps are often based on a limited number of life history characteristics indi
cative of requirements for early establishment, with the assumption that th
ese traits are correlated with growth requirements of larger individuals. W
e tested the validity of this assumption for Alseis blackiana, a common can
opy tree in central Panama, by examining its seed germination, seedling gro
wth, and sapling distribution, growth, and mortality. We found that the ear
ly life history of Alseis is characteristic of pioneer species: the seed ge
rmination rate was much higher in forest gaps than in the forest understory
, small seedlings were absent from the understory, and seedlings showed str
ong plastic responses to variation in light. Seedling relative growth rate,
leaf area production rate, and maximum carbon assimilation rates of Alseis
are much more similar to those of the pioneer tree Miconia argentea than t
o those of the non-pioneer tree Tetragastris panamensis. However, in contra
st to Miconia, established seedlings of Alseis are capable of remarkable pe
rsistence in the understory; in a 1-ha plot on Barro Colorado Island, the m
ortality rate for 722 saplings <1 cm dbh was <4% per year between 1986 and
1998. We suspect that shade tolerance in Alseis is achieved by both physiol
ogical and morphological adaptations, e.g., efficient light interception by
thin, nonoverlapping leaves, tolerance to litterfall damage, and a high re
sprouting capacity. These results show that existing functional group class
ifications do not account for the full range of seedling trait combinations
found in tropical trees and indicate that a gap requirement for seedling e
stablishment need not limit the abundance of adult individuals in a stand.