H. Setala et al., CONDITIONAL OUTCOMES IN THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PINE AND ECTOMYCORRHIZAL FUNGI IN RELATION TO BIOTIC AND ABIOTIC ENVIRONMENT, Oikos, 80(1), 1997, pp. 112-122
An increasing number of studies demonstrate the variable and context-d
ependent nature of mutualistic interactions, the outcome of which may
vary in space and time in response to abiotic and biotic factors. In t
his study we tested whether the intensity of grazing by soil fauna bri
ngs about different costs and benefits in the Scots pine-ectomycorrhiz
al (EM) fungi symbiosis with respect to nitrogen availability for the
pine. The experiment was conducted in transparent microcosms in which
a soil profile mimicking that of coniferous forest soil with Pinus syl
vestris seedlings was created. The seedlings were grown either in N-ri
ch or N-poor humus soil. The soils were defaunated, re-inoculated with
heterotrophic soil microbes, and one seedling of P. sylvestris - eith
er non-infected or infected with 3 species of EM fungi - was planted i
n the microcosms. Half of the microcosms were thereafter re-faunated w
ith diverse and numerically rich soil fauna typical to coniferous fore
st soil to represent intensive grazing pressure on EM fungi, while the
other half received bacterial feeding protozoans, and microbial feedi
ng nematodes only (representing strongly reduced grazing pressure). Th
e microcosms were incubated in a growth chamber with varying illuminat
ion and temperature regimes for two growing seasons of the pine. After
45 weeks ca 10 times more EM fungal biomass was found on pine roots g
rowing in N-poor soils than in N-rich soils. The amount of EM fungi wa
s significantly reduced by the complex and abundant faunal community,
particularly in N-poor soils, where the amount of EM fungi was less th
an 16% of that found in systems with reduced grazing pressure. The sho
ot and root production were significantly higher in the N-poor systems
than in the N-rich systems. Seedlings grown in the N-rich soils had a
markedly lower P:N-ratio (0.07) in the needles as compared to the one
s in the N-poor soils (0.14). Soil type and soil fauna had a significa
nt interaction on the total pine biomass production; in N-poor soils c
omplex fauna reduced the amount of pine biomass, whereas in N-rich soi
ls the effect of this fauna was negligible. Despite the clear faunal i
nduced changes in the biomass production of the fungal symbiont, and a
lthough the effects of grazing on pine growth were distinctly related
to the nitrogen status of the soil. the costs and benefits that determ
ine the net effects of the plant-fungus association were not unambiguo
usly related to feeding by fauna on EM fungi. We hypothesize that the
divergent influence of soil fauna in relation to pine growth between t
he two soil types was not associated with reduced costs by the EM fung
i for the pine but due to differences in the availability of P for pla
nt uptake in the soils.