Cj. Benesh et al., QUANTUM-MECHANICAL EQUIVALENT-PHOTON SPECTRUM FOR HEAVY-ION PHYSICS -REPLY, Physical review. C. Nuclear physics, 56(1), 1997, pp. 583-584
Shortcomings of a momentum-space treatment of strong absorption, as di
scussed in the preceding Comment, are only of concern at low projectil
e energies, gamma<1.5. At intermediate and high energies, for which th
e quantum-mechanical equivalent-photon spectrum is intended, the quant
um-mechanical cross sections are reduced relative to the semiclassical
results whether one treats Strong effects via a momentum-space or an
impact-parameter (spatial) cutoff. At these energies the origin of-the
discrepancy between the predictions of fully quantum-mechanical and t
he semiclassical calculations cannot be traced to differences in the t
reatment of strong-interaction effects. Rather, they arise from quantu
m effects neglected in the semiclassical calculations.