Two experiments were performed to evaluate the effects of three differ
ent elaborative activities on concept learning. Experiment 1 consisted
of 60 undergraduates, while Experiment 2 consisted of 54 undergraduat
es. In both experiments, subjects studied a passage which asked them t
o create personal examples of the target concepts, contrast the target
concepts, or expand on the effects of the target concepts. Subjects t
ook a criterion test which consisted of recall of concept definitions
and teaching examples, classification of novel examples, and problem s
olving scenarios. In both experiments, the condition which asked subje
cts to contrast the target concepts produced significantly better perf
ormance than the other two conditions. Possible explanations focus on:
(1) the degree to which the different elaborative activities influenc
e the richness and/or distinctiveness of the encoded information, and
(2) the relation among the focus of the elaborative activity, the expe
rimental text, and the measured criterion outcomes. (C) 1997 Academic
Press.