Y. Tindberg et al., Phe accuracy of serologic diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori infection in school-aged children of mixed ethnicity, HELICOBACT, 6(1), 2001, pp. 24-30
The present study evaluated two non-invasive diagnostic methods for H. pylo
ri infection in children, i.e. an in-house ELISA using sonicated Campylobac
ter jejuni antigen for absorption of cross-reacting antibodies and an immun
oblot kit (Helico Blot 2.0, Genelabs, Singapore). C-13 -Urea breath test (C
-13-UBT) was used as reference method. Sera and questionnaires were collect
ed from 695/858 (81%) Swedish school children with mixed ethnic backgrounds
within a cross-sectional, community-based study. Of 133 children with an E
LISA OD value of greater than or equal to0.1, all were screened with immuno
blot and 107 made a C-13-UBT. The negative controls were 34/37 children fro
m three school classes with an ELISA OD value of < 0.1 and volunteering for
a C-13-UBT. An adjusted cut-off level for the ELISA of OD value 0.22 resul
ted in a sensitivity of 97.8%, a specificity of 95.8% and a concordance ind
ex of 97.2%. The Helico Blot 2.0 had a sensitivity of 97.8%, a specificity
of 93.8% and a concordance index of 96.5%, The best concordance was seen fo
r the 26.5 kDa (98.6%), 30 kDa (95.7%) and 19.5 kDa (91.5%) antigens. The c
orresponding concordance index for CagA was 78%, for VacA 73.8% and for the
35kDa antigen 68.8%. A significant difference in the distribution of the 1
9.5 and 26.5 kDa bands but not of CagA/VacA was noted by ethnic background.
With an adjusted cut-off level for the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (
ELISA), both non-invasive methods were found to have an adequate performanc
e in a pediatric population. The differences in antibody response patterns
by ethnic background represent a caveat in the interpretation of serologica
l studies.