Purpose: This retrospective review was done to assess the prognosis and res
ponse in patients presenting with primitive neuroectodermal tumor admired w
ith germ cell tumor.
Materials and Methods: Of the 40 patients treated at our institution from 1
984 to 1999, 15 had initial stage I and 25 had initial metastatic disease,
Median followup after the diagnosis was 25 months (range 4 to 142).
Results, Of the 40 patients 15 presented with clinical stage I disease, inc
luding 9 treated with retroperitoneal lymph node dissection and 6 who elect
ed surveillance. Seven of the 9 patients had normal lymph nodes and all con
tinuously had no evidence of disease, Two of the 9 patients had lymph nodes
involved with teratoma with or without primitive neuroectodermal tumor. Re
troperitoneal relapse in 5 of the 6 patients on surveillance was treated wi
th cisplatin based chemotherapy followed by post-chemotherapy retroperitone
al lymph node dissection, Residual primitive neuroectodermal tumor was note
d in 4 of the 5 patients and only 3 of 6 are currently without disease at a
median followup Of 17 months (range 15 to 69). A total of 25 patients pres
ented with metastatic disease, of whom 23 underwent cisplatin based chemoth
erapy. Only 3 patients achieved complete remission with chemotherapy alone
and 2 of the 3 subsequently relapsed. Of the remaining 20 patients 16 under
went post-chemotherapy retroperitoneal lymph node dissection including 11 w
ith primitive neuroectodermal tumor in the resected specimen. Two of these
11 patients have continuously had no evidence of disease, while an addition
al 3 currently have no evidence of disease after further therapy, Teratoma
was present in the resected specimen in 5 of 16 patients, of whom 2 have co
ntinuously had no evidence of disease, while an additional 2 currently have
no evidence of disease after further surgical resection. Therefore, 11 of
25 patients who presented with metastatic disease currently have no evidenc
e of disease at a median followup of 19 months (range 2 to 111).
Conclusions: Primitive neuroectodermal tumor in the orchiectomy specimen ha
s adverse prognostic significance, This condition in the retroperitoneum is
potentially curable by retroperitoneal lymph node dissection but rarely er
adicated by chemotherapy, Therefore, we recommend retroperitoneal lymph nod
e dissection for all clinical stage I cases with primitive neuroectodermal
tumor in the orchiectomy specimen. Patients who present with metastatic pri
mitive neuroectodermal tumor should be treated aggressively with surgical r
esection as an integral part of the therapeutic strategy.