R. Haggerty et al., Tracer tests in a fractured dolomite 2. Analysis of mass transfer in single-well injection-withdrawal tests, WATER RES R, 37(5), 2001, pp. 1129-1142
We investigated multiple-rate diffusion as a possible explanation for obser
ved behavior in a suite of single-well injection-withdrawal (SWIW) tests co
nducted in a fractured dolomite. We first investigated the ability of a con
ventional double-porosity model and a multirate diffusion model to explain
the data. This revealed that the multirate diffusion hypothesis/model is co
nsistent with available data and is capable of matching all of the recovery
curves. Second, we studied the sensitivity of the SWIW curves to the distr
ibution of diffusion rate coefficients and other parameters. We concluded t
hat the SWIW test is very sensitive to the distribution of rate coefficient
s but is relatively insensitive to other flow and transport parameters such
as advective porosity and dispersivity. Third, we examined the significanc
e of the constant double-log late time slopes (-2.1 to -2.8), which are pre
sent in several data sets. The observed late time slopes are significantly
different than would be predicted by either conventional double-porosity or
single-porosity models and are believed to be a distinctive feature of mul
tirate diffusion. Fourth, we found that the estimated distributions of diff
usion rate coefficients are very broad, with the distributions spanning a r
ange of up to 3.6 orders of magnitude. Fifth, when both heterogeneity and s
olute drift are present, late time behavior similar to multirate mass trans
fer can occur. Although it is clear that multirate diffusion occurs in the
Culebra, the number of orders of magnitude of variability may be overestima
ted because of the combined effects of drift and heterogeneity.