Although core decompression is one of the more popular procedures for treat
ing avascular necrosis, considerable controversy exists concerning its safe
ty and effectiveness. The current authors review the results of a prospecti
ve study of 406 hips in 285 patients treated by one surgeon with core decom
pression and bone grafting. Patients were followed up for 2 to 14 years. Th
e outcome was determined by the change in the Harris hip score, quantitativ
e radiographic measurements, and need for total hip replacement. These hips
were compared with 55 hips in 39 patients treated non-operatively and with
historic controls. Five complications occurred after 406 procedures includ
ing two fractures that resulted from falls during the first postoperative m
onth. Of the 312 hips in 208 patients with a minimum 2-year followup, 36% o
f hips (113 hips in 90 patients) required hip replacement at a mean of 29 m
onths: 18 of 65 hips (28%) with Stage I disease; 45 of 133 hips (34%) with
Stage II disease; three of 13 hips (23%) with Stage III disease; and 45 of
92 hips (49%) with Stage IV disease. Before femoral head collapse (Stages I
and II combined) hip replacement was performed in 10 of 77 hips (14%) with
small lesions (A), 33 of 68 hips (48%) with intermediate lesions (B), and
20 of 48 hips (42%) with large lesions (C). Results as determined by change
s in Harris hip scores and radiographic progression were similar. Patients
who underwent core decompression and bone grafting have a very low complica
tion rate. In patients treated before femoral head collapse, the outcome is
significantly better than in patients who received symptomatic treatment.
The results are correlated with the stage and the size of the necrotic lesi
on.