M. Brink et al., Characteristics of the electronic structures of diabatically and adiabatically Z/E-isomerizing olefins in the T-1 state, J PHYS CH A, 105(16), 2001, pp. 4071-4083
Nonlocal gradient-corrected and hybrid density functional theory (DFT) have
been used to calculate T1 potential energy surfaces (PES), spin densities,
and geometries of ethylene and aromatic olefins of various sizes: ethylene
(1), styrene (2), stilbene (3), 1,1 -diphenylethylene (4), 1,4-bis-(1-prop
enyl)benzene (5), 1,3-divinylbenzene (6), and 2-(1-propenyl)anthracene (7).
Calculated properties were used to determine differences in electronic str
ucture of olefins that follow adiabatic vs diabatic Z/E-isomerization mecha
nisms. In the planar TI structure. the C=C bond in 1 is elongated to a sing
le bond, but in 7 it remains a double bond, archetypal of excitations in th
e olefinic bond and in the substituent, respectively. Changes in geometries
and spin-density distributions of 2-7 reveal that substituent aromaticitie
s vary along the Tl PES. For systems that isomerize diabatically (e.g., 2),
substituent aromaticity is regained in the 90 degrees twisted structure of
the C=C bond (3p*). This leads to stabilization and a minimum on the PES a
t 3p*. If the substituent of the planar T1 olefin fully can accommodate the
triplet biradical and still remain aromatic as in 7, aromaticity is instea
d reduced upon twist to 3p*, SO that the T1 PES has a barrier that is suita
ble for adiabatic isomerizations. The planar structures of olefins with sub
stituents that are partially antiaromatic in Ti (e.g., phenyl) can be stabi
lized by radical accepting groups in the proper positions (e.g., 5). In sum
mary, our calculations indicate that for an aryl-substituted olefin the str
ucture with the highest substituent aromaticity in TI corresponds to the mi
nimum on the TI PES of Z/E-isomerizations.