This paper explains why agencies sometimes encourage their ablest workers t
o perform an inferior task. I develop a model in which workers' outputs in
terms of the stated goal of the agency are surrounded with uncertainty. Whe
n workers are evaluated on the basis of their contributions to the stated g
oal of the agency, a high ability worker runs the risk of being perceived a
s a low ability worker. High ability workers are only willing to work for t
he agency if they are compensated for this risk. To avoid compensation the
agency may allow workers to perform a measurable, bur inferior, task.