Advances in structure determination of membrane proteins enable analysis of
the propensities of amino acids in extramembrane versus transmembrane loca
tions to be performed on the basis of structure rather than of sequence and
predicted topology. Using 29 available structures of integral membrane pro
teins with resolutions better than 4 Angstrom the distributions of amino ac
ids in the transmembrane domains were calculated. The results were compared
to analysis based on just the sequences of the same transmembrane alpha -h
elices and significant differences were found. The distribution of residues
between transmembrane alpha -helices and beta -strands was also compared.
Large hydrophobic (Phe, Leu, Ile, Val) residues showed a clear preference f
or the protein surfaces facing the lipids for beta -barrels, but in alpha -
helical proteins no such preference was seen: with these residues equally d
istributed between the interior and the surface of the protein. A notable e
xception to this was alanine, which showed a slight preference for the inte
rior of alpha -helical membrane proteins. Aromatic residues were found to f
ollow saddle-like distributions preferring to be located in the lipid/water
interfaces. The resultant 'aromatic belts' were spaced more closely for be
ta -barrel than for alpha -helical membrane proteins. Charged residues coul
d be shown to generally avoid surfaces facing the bilayer although they wer
e found to occur frequently in the transmembrane region of beta -barrels. I
ndeed detailed comparison between alpha -helical and beta -barrel proteins
showed many qualitative differences in residue distributions. This suggests
that there may be subtle differences in the factors stabilising beta -barr
els in bacterial outer membranes and alpha -helix bundles in all other memb
ranes. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.