The transition states for methane activation in liquid superacid have been
studied by experimentally determined secondary kinetic deuterium isotope ef
fects (SKIEs) and computational chemistry. For the first time, the SKIEs on
hydrogen/deuterium exchange of methane have been measured by using the met
hane isotopologues in homogeneous liquid superacid ((HF)-H-2/ SbF5). To ach
ieve high accuracy of the SKIEs, the rate constants for pairs of methane is
otopologues were simultaneously measured in the same superacid solution by
using NMR spectroscopy Density functional theory (DFT and high-level ab ini
tio methods have been employed to model possible intermediates and transiti
on states, assuming that the superacids involved in the exchange reactions
are H2F- ions solvated by HF Only the unsolvated superacid H2F- is found to
be strong enough to protonate methane. yielding the methonium ion solvated
by HF as a potential energy minimum. In contrast, the (HF)(x)-solvated H2F
- superacids (x = 1-4) do not appear to be strong enough to yield stable so
lvated methonium ions. However, such ions show up as parts of the transitio
n slates of the exchange in which the methonium ions are solvated by (HF)(x
). The calculated DFT activation barrier is in good agreement with that exp
erimentally observed.