Background: Concerns about possible risks of switching to mania associated
with antidepressants continue to interfere with the establishment of an opt
imal treatment paradigm for bipolar depression.
Method: The response of 44 patients meeting DSM-TV criteria for bipolar dis
order to naturalistic treatment was assessed for at least 6 weeks using the
Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale and the Bech-Rafaelson Mania Rat
ing Scale. Patients who experienced a manic or hypomanic switch were compar
ed with those who did not on several variables including age, sex, diagnosi
s (DSM-IV bipolar I vs. bipolar II), number of previous manic episodes, typ
e of antidepressant therapy used (electroconvulsive therapy vs. antidepress
ant drugs and, more particularly, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors [
SSRIs]), use and type of mood stabilizers (lithium vs. anticonvulsants), an
d temperament of the patient, assessed during a normothymic period using th
e hyperthymia component of the Semistructured Affective Temperament Intervi
ew.
Results: Switches to hypomania or mania occurred in 27% of all patients (N
= 12) (and in 24% of the subgroup of patients treated with SSRIs [8/33]); 1
6% (N = 7) experienced manic episodes, and 11% (N = 5) experienced hypomani
c episodes. Sex, age, diagnosis (bipolar I vs. bipolar II), and additional
treatment did not affect the risk of switching. The incidence of mood switc
hes seemed not to differ between patients receiving an anticonvulsant and t
hose receiving no mood stabilizer. In contrast, mood switches were less fre
quent in patients receiving lithium (15%, 4/26) than in patients not treate
d with lithium (44%, 8/18; p = .04). The number of previous manic episodes
did not affect the probability of switching, whereas a high score on the hy
perthymia component of the Semistructured Affective Temperament Interview w
as associated with a greater risk of switching (p = .008).
Conclusion: The frequency of mood switching associated with acute antidepre
ssant therapy may be reduced by lithium treatment. Particular attention sho
uld be paid to patients with a hyperthymic temperament, who have a greater
risk of mood switches.