Comparison between two artificial shelter units and timed manual collections for detecting peridomestic Triatoma infestans (Hemiptera : Reduviidae) in rural northwestern Argentina
Re. Gurtler et al., Comparison between two artificial shelter units and timed manual collections for detecting peridomestic Triatoma infestans (Hemiptera : Reduviidae) in rural northwestern Argentina, J MED ENT, 38(3), 2001, pp. 429-436
A ne2 artificial shelter unit was compared with segments of bamboo cane lin
ed with pleated filter paper for detecting peridomestic Triatoma infestans
Klug at Amama and nearby rural villages in northwestern Argentina. The new
shelter unit consisted of a black plastic, wide-mouthed jar with a screw ca
p On the top, and a removable central structure made of pleated corrugated
paper. In devices exposed from February to December 1999 at 24 sites positi
ve for T infestans by timed manual collections with an irritant in April 19
99, the cumulative percentage of sites with any sign of infestation detecte
d by the shelter unit increased from 71% after 2 mo to 96% after 10 mo, whe
reas bamboo cane units concurrently detected only 12-42% of the sites. Sens
itivity increased with time of exposure and the abundance of T infestans pe
r site. In 19 sites negative for T. infestans by inspection. shelters incre
asingly detected infestation at 16-63% of sites after 10 mo, whereas the ba
mboo canes only detected one infestation. Shelter units inspected three tim
es over an Ii-mo period were significantly more sensitive than a single man
ual search with an irritant performed in March 2000. Our study provided con
clusive field evidence that the shelter unit was more sensitive for detecti
ng peridomestic T infestans than were timed manual searches, the standard r
eference method, or bamboo cane units. Rapid timed searches by skilled bug
collectors during the early surveillance phase overlooked many peridomestic
populations that. in the absence of control, inevitably would increase in
abundance and repopulate treated areas.