D. Canet et al., A comprehensive analysis of multifield N-15 relaxation parameters in proteins: Determination of N-15 chemical shift anisotropies, J AM CHEM S, 123(19), 2001, pp. 4567-4576
This study deals with the exploitation of the three classical N-15 relaxati
on parameters (the longitudinal relaxation rate, R-1, the transverse relaxa
tion rate, R-2, and the H-1-N-15 cross-relaxation rate, sigma (NH)) measure
d at several magnetic fields in uniformly N-15-labeled proteins. Spectral d
ensities involved in R-1, R-2 and sigma (NH) are analyzed according to the
functional form A + B/(1 + omega (2)tau (2)(x)), where tau (s) is the corre
lation time associated with slow motions sensed by the NH vector at the lev
el of the residue to which it belongs. The coefficient B provides a realist
ic view of the backbone dynamics, whereas A is associated with fast local m
otions. According to the "model free approach", B can be identified with 2
tau S-s(2) where S is the generalized order parameter. The correlation time
tau (s) is determined from the field dependency of the relaxation paramete
rs while A and B are determined through linear equations. This simple data
processing is needed for obtaining realistic error bars based on a statisti
cal approach. This proved to be the key point for validating an extended an
alysis aiming at the determination of nitrogen chemical shift anisotropy. T
he protein C12A-p8(MTCP1) has been chosen as a model for this study. It wil
l be shown that all data (obtained at five magnetic field strengths corresp
onding to proton resonance of 400, 500, 600, 700, and 800 MHz) are very con
sistently fitted provided that a specific effective correlation time associ
ated with slow motions is defined for each residue. This is assessed by sma
ll deviations between experimental and recalculated values, which, in all c
ases, remain within experimental uncertainty. This strategy makes needless
elaborate approaches based on the combination of several slow motions or th
eir possible anisotropy. Within the core of the protein tau (s) fluctuates
in a relatively narrow range (with a mean value of 6.15 ns and a root-mean-
square deviation of 0.36 ns) while it is considerably reduced at the protei
n extremities (down to similar to3 ns). To a certain extent, these fluctuat
ions are correlated with the protein structure. A is not obtained with suff
icient accuracy to be valuably discussed. Conversely, order parameters deri
ved from B exhibit a significant correlation with the protein structure. Fi
nally, the multi-field analysis of the evolution of longitudinal and transv
erse relaxation rates has been refined by allowing the N-15 chemical shift
anisotropy (csa) to vary residue by residue. Within uncertainties (derived
here on a statistical basis) an almost constant value is obtained. This str
ongly indicates an absence of correlation between the experimental value of
this parameter obtained for a given residue in the protein, the nature of
this residue, and the possible involvement of this residue in a structured
area of the protein.