The purpose of this paper is to determine the optimal mutation rate for ran
dom mutagenesis procedures used to make mutant libraries for subsequent scr
eening. When the mutation rate is low, the probability of achieving a rare
beneficial mutation is low. When the mutation rate is high, the probability
of producing lethal mutations which result in loss of function is also hig
h. We demonstrate that between these two extremes, an optimal mutation rate
exists for experimental gene improvement. This rate depends strongly on th
e number of simultaneous mutations required for a beneficial change of the
gene, but only weakly on the number of possible lethal mutations. This mode
l predicts that when mutagenesis is performed at the optimum mutation Fate,
at least 63% (1 - e(-1)) of the cloned genes in a mutant library will be n
on-functional. (C) 2001 Academic Press.