Long-term outcome of meniscectomy: symptoms, function, and performance tests in patients with or without radiographic osteoarthritis compared to matched controls
Em. Roos et al., Long-term outcome of meniscectomy: symptoms, function, and performance tests in patients with or without radiographic osteoarthritis compared to matched controls, OSTEO CART, 9(4), 2001, pp. 316-324
Objective: To describe the long-term influence of meniscectomy on pain, fun
ctional limitations, and muscular performance. To assess the effects of rad
iographic osteoarthritis (OA), gender and age on these outcomes in patients
with meniscectomy.
Design: 159 subjects (35 women), mean age 53 years, were examined 19 (17-28
) years after open meniscectomy. Self-reported symptoms and function were a
ssessed, performance tests were carried out and radiographs were taken. Six
ty-eight age- and gender-matched controls were examined likewise. The data
was analysed in two steps. First, subjects with meniscectomy were compared
to the controls, and subgroup analyses were carried out with regard to radi
ographic OA, gender and age. Second, similar comparisons were carried out w
ithin the meniscectomized group.
Results: Meniscectomized subjects reported significantly (P<0.001) more sym
ptoms and functional limitations than did controls. This was also true when
operated subjects without OA were compared to controls without OA. Within
the meniscectomized group, severe radiographic OA (joint space narrowing gr
ade 2 or more) and female gender, but not older age, was associated with mo
re symptoms and functional limitations. Meniscectomy was associated with wo
rse muscular performance, Female gender and older age were associated with
worse muscular performance in the study group.
Conclusions: Meniscectomy is associated with long-term symptoms and functio
nal limitations, especially in women. Patients who had developed severe rad
iographic OA experienced more symptoms and functional limitations. Age did
not influence self-reported outcomes, however older age was associated with
worse muscular performance. (C) 2001 OsteoArthritis Research Society Inter
national.