Several methods were used to type 64 clinical isolates of coagulase-negativ
e staphylococci (CNS) derived from hospitals in Morocco. The clinical isola
tes originated principally from blood cultures and wound sources. These iso
lates provided the opportunity to substantially compare the proficiency of
developing molecular techniques with conventional phenotypic tests for use
in the identification of clinical staphylococci. The following molecular me
thods were examined: Utility ribotyping analysis (Ribotyping); PCR analysis
performed with 16S-23S ribosomal-DNA intergenic spacer (ITS-PCR); PCR-base
d random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD). The results obtained by the mole
cular techniques were contrasted to those of conventional phenotypic tests.
Conventional phenotypic tests allowed the outright recognition of the majo
rity of isolates (50/64). These 50 isolates were subdivided into 33 novobio
cin-susceptible and 17 novobiocin-resistant strains of CNS. However, 2 othe
r novobiocin-susceptible and 12 other novobiocin-resistant isolates remaine
d unclassified by these tests. There was a good agreement between the conve
ntional phenotypic tests and RAPD for the 33 novobiocin-susceptible isolate
s. But, the RAPD technique permitted the assignment of the two unidentified
novobiocin-susceptible isolates to the Staphylococcus hominis species. A c
omplete correlation was obtained between the three molecular tools for reco
gnition of the 12 novobiocin-resistant isolates that were not identified by
phenotypic typing; these were in fact identified as 5 Staphylococcus cohni
i and 4 Staphylococcus equorum. Three isolates remained unidentified by all
three systems of molecular techniques. (C) 2001 Editions scientifiques et
medicales Elsevier SAS.