Sj. Atlas et al., Surgical and nonsurgical management of sciatica secondary to a lumbar discherniation - Five-year outcomes from the Maine Lumbar Spine Study, SPINE, 26(10), 2001, pp. 1179-1187
Study Design. A prospective cohort study.
Objective. To assess 5-year outcomes for patients with sciatica caused by a
lumbar disc herniation treated surgically or nonsurgically.
Summary of Background Data. There is limited knowledge about long-term trea
tment outcomes of sciatica caused by a lumbar disc herniation, particularly
the relative benefits of surgical and conservative therapy in contemporary
clinical practice.
Methods. Eligible, consenting patients recruited from the practices of orth
opedic surgeons, neurosurgeons, and occupational medicine physicians throug
hout Maine had baseline interviews with mailed follow-up questionnaires at
3, 6, and 12 months and annually thereafter. Clinical data were obtained at
baseline from a physician questionnaire. Outcomes included patient-reporte
d symptoms of leg and back pain, functional status, satisfaction, and emplo
yment and compensation status.
Results. Of 507 patients initially enrolled, 5-year outcomes were available
for 402 (79.3%) patients: 220 (80%) treated surgically and 182 (78.4%) tre
ated nonsurgically. Surgically treated patients had worse baseline symptoms
and functional status than those initially treated nonsurgically. By 5 yea
rs 19% of surgical patients had undergone at least one additional lumbar sp
ine operation, and 16% of nonsurgical patients had opted for at least one l
umbar spine operation. Overall, patients treated initially with surgery rep
orted better outcomes. At the 5-year follow-up, 70% of patients initially t
reated surgically reported improvement in their predominant symptom (back o
r leg pain) versus 56% of those initially treated nonsurgically (P < 0.001)
. Similarly, a larger proportion of surgical patients reported satisfaction
with their current status (63% vs. 46%, P < 0.001). These differences pers
isted after adjustment for other determinants of outcome. The relative adva
ntage of surgery was greatest early in follow-up and narrowed over 5 years.
There was no difference in the proportion of patients receiving disability
compensation at the 5-year follow-up. The least symptomatic patients at ba
seline did well regardless of initial treatment, although function improved
more in the surgical group.
Conclusions. For patients with moderate or severe sciatica, surgical treatm
ent was associated with greater improvement than nonsurgical treatment at 5
years. However, patients treated surgically were as likely to be receiving
disability compensation, and the relative benefit of surgery decreased ove
r time.