Ma. Lallemand et al., Maternal serum anti-D antibody concentrations monitoring and transfusion practices in obstetrics in France: a preliminary study., ANN FR A R, 20(4), 2001, pp. 325-336
Objectives: In obstetrics, transfusion medicine is involved because of the
risk of Rh isoimmunisation and of transfusion at delivery. In France, altho
ugh these two situations have led to legal or professional recommendations,
practices appear to be very different from one institution or one physicia
n to another.
Study design: Retrospective study.
Methods: A questionnaire using both direct questions and clinical cases was
sent to all members of the French obstetric anaesthetists association (nam
ed CARO).
Results: One hundred and seventy-eight questionnaires (response rate 17.1%)
were returned. Monitoring of anti-D antibody concentrations during pregnan
cy was performed in accordance with the legal recommendation (14/02/1992) i
n only 3.9% (Rh+) and 19% (Rh-) of women. Blood samples were performed eith
er too often or too rarely in 39 to 72% of responses. At delivery, an immed
iate assessment of anti-D antibody concentration was required in almost 100
% by the specialist on call in the blood bank while this measurement was co
nsidered necessary by only 80% of anaesthetists responding to the questionn
aire. The distance between the maternity and the blood bank is greater than
14 km in 19% of responses and the largest time interval reported to obtain
red cell concentrates was greater than 145 min in 18% of responses. Autolo
gous blood transfusion is described as being used routinely in only 23% of
responses.
Conclusion: Significant failures in practice patterns and organisation of c
are are suggested by the responses to this questionnaire. This should stimu
late a national debate to improve adequacy of practices to legal and profes
sional recommendations and to review blood distribution to maternities in t
his country. (C) 2001 Editions scientifiques et medicales Elsevier SAS.