Jw. Gamel et Rl. Vogel, COMPARISON OF PARAMETRIC AND NONPARAMETRIC SURVIVAL METHODS USING SIMULATED CLINICAL-DATA, Statistics in medicine, 16(14), 1997, pp. 1629-1643
We derived three parametric survival models (the log-normal, log legit
, and Weibull) from the clinical data of chemotherapy trials for stage
II breast cancer. We then used these models to generate simulated sur
vival data, which we analysed using both parametric (log-normal) and n
on-parametric (logrank, Gray-Tsiatis and Laska-Meisner) methods. With
limited follow-up (5 years), the non-parametric tests had greater powe
r than the log-normal model. This advantage diminished, however, with
extended follow-up (15 years). Furthermore, only the log-normal model
could distinguish reliably a survival advantage due to an increase in
cured fraction from an advantage due to an increase in time to failure
. (C) 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.