Ar. Tait et al., Parents' preferences for participation in decisions made regarding their child's anaesthetic care, PAEDIATR AN, 11(3), 2001, pp. 283-290
Background: The traditional paternalistic approach to medical decision-maki
ng is moving towards a climate of greater patient and/or surrogate involvem
ent. Despite this, there is considerable debate regarding patient preferenc
es for participation in medical decisionmaking and its effect on patient sa
tisfaction and outcome. This study was designed to examine parents' prefere
nces for participation in decisions regarding their child's anaesthetic car
e and to determine if active participation is associated with greater paren
tal satisfaction.
Methods: Three hundred and eight parents of children scheduled to undergo e
lective surgical procedures were asked to complete a questionnaire detailin
g information regarding their preferences for participation in decisions ma
de regarding their child's anaesthetic care. Parents were classified as bei
ng passive, shared, or active decision makers.
Results: Overall, parents evidenced a preference for shared decisionmaking
with the anaesthetist. Parents preferred to be passive with respect to intr
aoperative pain management but active with respect to their presence when t
heir child wakes up. There were no differences between active, shared and p
assive decision-makers with respect to their satisfaction with anaesthetic
care and their participation in decision-making. However, 32.1% of parents
stated that they would have preferred more involvement in decision-making.
These parents were significantly less satisfied with their child's care tha
n those who felt that their participation had been adequate.
Conclusions: This study highlights specific areas in which parents would pr
efer a more active role in decision-making and, as such, may serve to focus
anaesthetists' efforts to educate parents with respect to the various opti
ons available for their child's care.