Rationale: Recently, a number of studies have challenged the finding that a
cute tryptophan depletion (TD) increases depressive symptoms in medicated,
formerly depressed patients. The present study examined the effects of acut
e nutritional TD on remitted depressed patients currently treated with sele
ctive serotonin reuptake inhibitors. In an attempt to clarify conflicting e
arlier findings, the effects of a number of clinical variables on outcome w
ere also investigated. Methods: Ten patients underwent TD in a double-blind
, controlled, balanced crossover fashion. The control session followed the
procedure of Krahn et al. (1996 Neuropsychopharmacology 15:325-328). Sessio
ns were 5-8 days apart. Results: TD was significantly related to increased
scores on clinician-rated depression and anxiety scales, and on self-rated
depression, anxiety, and somatic symptoms. The control challenge had no eff
ect, despite the fact that the reductions in plasma tryptophan during the c
entral session were unexpectedly high. Some evidence was found for a thresh
old in the relationship between reduction of plasma tryptophan and mood res
ponse. Conclusions: The mood effect of TD in medicated, formerly depressed
patients was confirmed. A threshold may exist for mood effects following TD
, implying that recent negative findings may have been caused by insufficie
nt depletion. No other predicting or mediating factors were identified, alt
hough the variable "history of response pattern, to medication" deserves fu
rther study.