Treatments intended to slow the progression of chronic diseases are often h
ypothesized to reduce the rate of further injury to a biological system wit
hout improving the current level of functioning. In this situation. the tre
atment effect may be negligible for patients whose disease would have been
stable without the treatment hut would be expected to be an increasing func
tion of the progression rate in patients with worsening disease. This artic
le considers a variation of the Laird-Ware mixed effects model in which the
effect of the treatment on the slope of a longitudinal outcome is assumed
to be proportional to the progression rate for patients with progressive di
sease. Inference based on maximum likelihood and a generalized estimating e
quations procedure is considered. Under the proportional effect assumption,
the precision of the estimated treatment effect carl be increased by incor
porating the functional relationship between the model parameters and the v
ariance of the outcome variable. particularly when the magnitude of the mea
n slope of the outcome is small compared with the standard deviation of the
slopes. An example from a study of chronic renal disease is used to illust
rate insights provided by the proportional effect model that may be overloo
ked with models assuming additive treatment effects.