In this article, the authors develop an attribution framework for evaluatin
g the investment performance of institutional investors such as insurance c
ompanies. The model is useful in identifying the investment skills of insur
ance companies. This is accomplished by developing a dual benchmark for the
investor that is focused toward the two objectives of the investor, namely
the maximization of shareholder value and the protection of the value of t
he policyholders. For each objective, the authors develop a different bench
mark portfolio, which are joined together to form the dual benchmark portfo
lio. As a result, their model achieves a balance between these two objectiv
es and reduces agency costs.