Rearrangements involving the phenonium ion were investigated by means of a
B3LYP/6-311G-(d,p) study in which the effect of solvent has been incorporat
ed by using a PCM solvation model. A rationalization of the whole set of ex
perimental facts reported both in the gas phase and in solution was possibl
e thanks to the characterization of protonated benzocyclobutene as a minimu
m energy structure and, particularly, to the important preferential stabili
zation in solution of the TS for the isomerization of the phenonium ion to
the alpha -methylbenzyl ion, which reduces the Gibbs energy barrier of 26.6
kcal/mol for this process in the gas phase to a more accessible one of 18.
7 kcal/mol in solution.