Hs. Shannon et al., OVERVIEW OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ORGANIZATIONAL AND WORKPLACE FACTORS AND INJURY RATES, Safety science, 26(3), 1997, pp. 201-217
This paper summarizes data from ten studies examining the relationship
between organizational and workplace factors and injury rates. The st
udies were identified from a systematic literature search, as well as
from other sources, and were included if they reported comparisons amo
ng at least 20 workplaces. Factors that were examined in at least two
studies were identified. Their relationship with injury rates was dete
rmined. It was nor possible to make quantitative comparisons between s
tudies. We looked for 'consistency' or 'contradiction' in the relation
ships, Among the variables 'consistency' associated with lower injury
rates were: empowerment of the workforce (in general matters); delegat
ion of safety activities; and an active role (in health and safety) of
top management. Among the 'contradictory' variables were the level an
d use of discipline for safety violations; and several others that wer
e contradictory only in subgroups of the same study. We discuss the li
mitations of synthesizing results from the diverse studies. (C) 1997 E
lsevier Science Ltd.