Va. Hampshire et al., Thoracoscopy as a nonpharmacotherapeutic research modification for limiting postoperative chest pain, J INVES SUR, 14(2), 2001, pp. 109-120
Diminished tissue injury and shortened clinical recovery are benefits of us
ing an endoscopic approach for patients needing operative procedure. In the
course of developing an experimental model requiring procurement of topogr
aphically precise lung biopsy specimens, we sought to apply thoracoscopy as
a research alternative to thoracotomy. In addition, we investigated the in
fluence of thoracoscopy on postprocedure recovery practices using rabbits d
ivided into four treatment groups. Rabbit groups 1 and 2 underwent thoracos
copy and lung biopsy while maintained by one-lung anesthesia. Additionally,
group 2 had ketoprofen and bupivacaine HCl analgesics injected for treatme
nt during postprocedure recovery. These two groups were compared to control
rabbits in groups 3 and 4, which underwent inhalant anesthesia without tho
racoscopy. Control group 3 also received the injection analgesic combinatio
n. During recovery, rabbit behavior was systematically assessed for evidenc
e of pain. No behavior considered indicative of pain needing intervention w
as observed regardless of treatment group. Limited changes in plasma cortic
osterone, catecholamines, and prostaglandin E-2 levels measured during reco
very were difficult to associate with any treatment. Unexpectedly, signific
antly different mean corticosterone and catecholamines levels were detected
in rabbits given the injection analgesic combination in the absence of tho
racoscopic procedure, as compared to other treatment groups. The results hi
ghlight the importance of awareness that analgesic drug administration has
the potential to alter homeostasis and affect interpretation of some study
findings by its own guise. Correlation of the mean pain study results with
plasma biochemical data supports preferential use of thoracoscopy as a refi
nement for limiting postprocedural pain in research models.