We report the discovery of an extremely rich, previously undescribed Caribb
ean late Miocene to early Pliocene ichthyofauna represented by one hundred
forty species of elasmobranchs and teleosteans from the Cubagua Formation,
northeastern Venezuela. The fauna exhibits significant ecological differenc
es compared with common neritic Caribbean Neogene assemblages. The bathymet
ric distributions of taxa, based on living counterparts, ranges from 0 to 1
00 m depth. The exceptional co-occurrence of deep water (epipelagic, mesope
lagic and benthopelagic), and shallow water (neritic) taxa is best interpre
ted as the consequence of ocean upwelling in the proximity to the deep-wate
r Cariaco Trench. Patterns of predator and prey are established and corrobo
rate upwelling. Special remarks are made regarding previously unknown late
Miocene to early Pliocene Caribbean ichthyofaunas, the absence or rarity of
reported fossil taxa in the Recent Caribbean fauna, and a paleo- upwelling
indicator (Lampadena jacksoni new species).