The objective of this paper is twofold: (a) to explore different approaches
in reviewing records based on a literature review of studies of audits of
patient records and (b) to apply these approaches on a sample of records to
illuminate consequences of their application.
The method used was a literature review of papers on recording of nursing c
are (n = 56). Based on our findings, an audit of a stratified sample of rec
ords (n = 298) from Swedish community health care and nursing homes was per
formed applying the different approaches for auditing previously described
in the literature.
The review showed that audits of patient records were performed using four
different approaches with varying aims. The focus of the four approaches ca
n be described as formal structure, process comprehensiveness, knowledge-ba
sed and concordance with actual care. The results of this study suggest tha
t audits of patient records should not be solely limited to encompass the f
ormal structure of recording. To avoid a superficial picture or a false sen
se of high quality and to obtain a more complete and reliable portrait of t
he quality of recording, we suggest the process comprehensiveness approach
in combination with a critical review of the knowledge base for the assessm
ent, diagnosis and interventions of patient records.