R. Wiles et S. Barnard, Physiotherapists and evidence based practice: An opportunity or threat to the profession?, SOC RES ONL, 6(1), 2001, pp. NIL_127-NIL_144
The profession of physiotherapy in the UK is undergoing a period of change.
Prominent among these aspects of change is the movement to evidence based
practice (EBP). EBP is a central element of policy in the National Health S
ervice (NHS). It is being implemented in physiotherapy as a means of securi
ng contracts with purchasers but also as a means of contesting challenges f
rom alternative practitioners and health professionals to the areas of work
that physiotherapists view as their territory. Using data collected from a
qualitative study of 56 physiotherapists of different grades working in di
fferent sectors of the NHS, this paper explores physiotherapists' views of
EBP and the impact that they expect it to have on professional boundaries a
nd on the status and practice of physiotherapy. The study indicated that ph
ysiotherapists' views may differ according to their position in the profess
ion. Senior physiotherapists appeared to view the development of EBP as a t
hreat to the profession which would decrease professional autonomy and the
status of the profession. In contrast, junior and superintendent physiother
apists appeared to view EBP as an opportunity for strengthening the profess
ion. The impact EBP will have on the profession of physiotherapy and its re
lationships with a range of health professionals is as yet unknown as are t
he responses that physiotherapists are likely to have to this development.
This study identifies the areas in which conflicts are likely to be played
out. A focus for future research analysing the impact of EBP is suggested.