Autonomic nervous system (ANS) balance was assessed in women with and witho
ut irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) using laboratory tests of function (ie, e
xpiratory/inspiratory ratio, Valsalva, posture changes, and cold presser) a
nd spectral and nonspectral measures of heart rate variability (HRV). Women
with (N = 103) and without IBS (N = 49) were recruited, interviewed, then
completed a laboratory assessment and wore a 24-hr Holter monitor Analysis
using the entire sample showed little difference between IBS and control wo
men and between subgroups with IBS on either laboratory measures or 24-hr H
RV measures. However, analysis restricted to those women with severe IBS sy
mptoms showed quite pronounced differences between two IBS subgroups on 24-
hr HRV measures. Parasympathetic tone was significantly lower and ANS balan
ce was significantly higher in the constipation-predominant compared to the
diarrhea-predominant group. Subgroups of women with IBS do differ in ANS f
unction as measured by 24-hr HRV; however, these differences are only appar
ent among women with severe symptoms. These findings point out the importan
ce of considering symptom severity when interpreting studies of IBS.