Hysteresis loops are often seen in experiments at first order phase transfo
rmations when the system goes out of equilibrium, such as in the supercooli
ng of liquids and in magnets. The nonequilibrium, zero-temperature random-f
ield Ising model has been studied as a model for the hysteretic behavior of
these transformations. As disorder is added, one finds a transition where
the jump in the saturation hysteresis loop (corresponding to an infinite av
alanche) decreases to zero. At this transition the model exhibits power law
distributions of noise (avalanches), universal behavior, and a diverging l
ength scale [O. Perkovic, K. Dahmen, and J. P. Sethna, Phys. Rev. B 59, 610
6 (1999)]. Interestingly, not only the saturation loops but also subloops r
eflect this critical point, and at the critical disorder one finds history-
induced critical scaling. We present simulation results for histories in sy
stems of almost 14 million spins. Concentric inner subloops are found to re
semble rescaled saturation loops at effectively higher (possibly correlated
) disorder. In addition, avalanche size distributions for the inner subloop
s are collapsed using Widom scaling methods. The resulting exponents and sc
aling functions are shown to differ from those corresponding to the saturat
ion loop. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.