Jas. Finkelstein et al., Maternal control and adolescent depression: Ethnic differences among clinically referred girls, J YOUTH ADO, 30(2), 2001, pp. 155-171
The relationship between perceived maternal control and depression was exam
ined in I I I urban adolescent girls seeking psychological services at an o
utpatient mental health center in the Midwest. This study sought to clarify
inconsistent findings in earlier research linking parental control and ado
lescent depression by examining urban girls with mental health problems and
by testing ethnic background as a moderator of the general relationship. D
ata were collected using self-administered questionnaires of adolescent gir
ls' depressive symptoms, and perceptions of their mothers' parenting styles
. Analyses did nor detect a significant association between maternal contro
l and depression in the combined sample of adolescent girls; however, findi
ngs were moderated by the ethnicity of the girls. Once ethnicity was includ
ed. no relation between control and depression was found for Caucasian and
Latina girls, bur high control was linked to less depression among African
American girls. These findings highlight the importance of ethnicity and ge
nder in child rearing and adolescent depression and stress the need for mor
e culturally sensitive conceptualizations of depression.