Bk. Mohanti et al., Palliative care education and training during residency: A survey among residents at a tertiary care hospital, NAT MED J I, 14(2), 2001, pp. 102-104
Background. Palliative care is the active total care of patients in advance
d and incurable stages of cancer. More than 70% of all cancer patients in I
ndia require palliative care for relief of pain, other symptoms and psychos
ocial distress. The need for education and training in palliative care has
been emphasized by the World Health Organization (WHO) during the past 15 y
ears. This survey aimed to assess the awareness, clinical knowledge, and ed
ucation and training aspects of palliative care among the clinical resident
s of a tertiary care hospital.
Methods. During January and February 1999, a total of 100 residents were as
ked to respond to a questionnaire on palliative care education and training
during residency. The questionnaire consisted of 10 questions (each questi
on with 3 different responses). Awareness regarding palliative care was ass
essed by 3 questions; clinical knowledge by 4 questions; and education and
training obtained during residency by 3 questions, Comparisons were made us
ing the Chi-square test between the oncology and non-oncology resident grou
ps.
Results Forty-nine residents (23 oncology and 26 nononcology) responded to
the survey. Awareness that palliative care involves active total care was l
acking in 8 (16%) residents. The cost of palliative care in India was consi
dered high by 17 (65%) non-oncology residents and 21 (43%) of the whole gro
up. Hospice, as the right place for palliative care, was chosen by 14 (61%)
oncology and 3 (11.5%) non-oncology residents (p=0.0003). In the whole gro
up, 21 (43%) believed that palliative care could be provided on an outpatie
nt basis. Pain, depression and cachexia were identified as the most distres
sing symptoms of patients with incurable cancer. Seventeen (83%) oncology a
nd 4 (15%) non-oncology residents (p=0.000) knew how to use the WHO step-la
dder for cancer pain relief. All oncology residents and 10 (38%) non-oncolo
gy residents preferred the oral route for providing medications for pain re
lief (p=0.0001). The didactic education and training imparted during reside
ncy was considered as 'not enough' by 39% of oncology and 62% of non-oncolo
gy residents (51% overall). The confidence to deliver quality palliative ca
re was lacking in 43% and 58% of oncology and non-oncology residents, respe
ctively.
Conclusion, Clinicians in India need to be provided focused skills and trai
ning for them to be able deliver quality palliative care to the large numbe
r of patients with incurable cancer. The cost of palliative care and the op
timum place to deliver it, the symptoms of advanced cancer, pain relief and
symptom control methods and quality of life in end-stage cancer patients a
re some aspects that should be an integral part of clinical residency progr
ammes.